What started as a romantic trip out of the city for my husband's birthday -- a walk along the reservoir, dinner at a fancy restaurant, and a concert in quaint Tarrytown -- ended up being a needlessly melodramatic bummer.*
While enjoying a wonderful meal at Tarry Tavern -- Damian had pumpkin soup and pan-roasted Rohan duck breast while I opted for the honeycrisp apple, endive and blue cheese salad followed by bucatini all' Amatriciana -- we double-checked to see if there was an opening act for Neko Case, whom neither of us had seen in concert before after two decades of fandom of her most famous side project, the New Pornographers.
Once determining there was, we leisurely had dessert (white chocolate bread pudding) and coffee before heading a few doors down to the Tarrytown Music Hall, a charming venue built in the late 19th century where we had seen Graham Nash years ago, also for Damian's birthday.
We were very excited!
When we arrived at about 7:20, the opener -- a singer/guitarist and songwriter named Imaad Wasif -- was finishing a cover of Bill Withers's "Ain't No Sunshine," at which point he announced that he was going to "break the fuckin' fourth wall" and jumped down into the audience as he began his next song.
Damian and I immediately tensed up. Neither of us can even attend drag shows because that type of audience interaction makes us both incredibly uncomfortable, so it was unexpected -- and unnerving -- to have it happening in a seated theater filled with people who were largely over 50. (I've been very open about
my battles with social anxiety, for which I take prescription drugs.)
After making his way through the crowd, Wasif eventually stopped for a second near a man and woman in the row directly in front of us, which caused us to further recoil. (At the exact same time a server happened to be bringing drinks to people near us -- which isn't even something typically done at this venue -- further complicating our ability to make sense of what happened next.)
Wasif then casually walked back to the stage, at which point he blurted out something about just being a “messenger of God” -- and then he started berating “New York” for “doing this to him” as he stormed off, saying he could no longer perform after someone in the crowd was “taking swings” at him. (Others heard him say he'd been "punched" while another person told me Wasif told him after the show that he had been put in a "headlock.")
Huh?
A few minutes later, the man in the row in front of us was removed -- apparently based on this. Curiously, the security guards hadn't come anywhere near him until after Wasif's meltdown. In fact, Damian recalls that they didn’t come until after Wasif had exited the stage completely, as if it took a while for even them to figure out who was being accused of something.
Everyone started looking around, completely confused. I asked the people sitting directly next to "the bad guy" what had happened, and they too had no idea.
Nearly two hours passed with no announcements and no explanation as to what was going on. Easily 90% of the crowd or more had not even a slight clue about the alleged “incident" -- many weren't even there when the opener was on -- as rumors began to swirl that Neko was canceling her performance.
Groups of people began leaving.
Finally she came out at about 9:10, immediately snapping that she was “fuckin’ pissed” -- and then threatened the crowd that if we "said anything" she would “leave.” (Damian recalls her saying something to the effect of she'd leave "if we did anything shitty.")
Huh?
Again, most people had little to no idea what was happening -- so another sizable group walked out, understandably offended by this hostile greeting after having waited hours.
The mood was tense as the band began to play but after a few songs someone tried to lighten things up, by screaming: “We’re sorry about one asshole!”
Rather than seize the opportunity to make it clear that we were all on the same "side," she seemed even more disgruntled -- reprimanding him, saying that she had asked that no one say anything. (I had been looking forward to this event for months and now felt like I had done something wrong.)
From there, she finally tried to offer some sort of conciliatory words, explaining that she wasn’t “pissed” at us, she was pissed about being asked to “mask being pissed.”
I don't think anyone quite understood what that meant. (To me it sounded uncomfortably similar to when Joan Crawford maniacally told daughter Tina in "Mommie Dearest" that she wasn't mad at her, she was "mad at the dirt," as they scrubbed the bathroom tile, Comet flying through the air.) But then Neko added: "That doesn’t mean we can’t enjoy this fucked-up evening.”
Before long, it became apparent that her decision to not start at the typical time was going to cause the show to be cut short. She then, at last, relayed her first hint of gratitude to a formerly packed house that had been made to feel guilty for giving her money, saying she appreciated that we had "stuck around" for this “fucked-up night” and then signed off, no time for the rest of the set much less an encore due to the curfew. (Grumpiness aside, she sounded great.)
At this point I don't even think what actually transpired between the opener and the man who was ejected really matters. Eyewitness accounts are notoriously inconsistent. But suffice to say that everyone agrees that no one was "punched" -- which is how it was described on social media last night -- and no one was assaulted. (As I said, security had zero reaction until they were sicced on the guy, and neither we nor the people to the left noticed anything untoward.)
The version I think is most likely came from the two women sitting directly behind the man and the woman he was with who said this: The opener -- who was touching people as he made his way through the crowd and had actually sat on another audience member's lap as he came toward our section -- is said to have reached out to run his hand through the man's hair (or possibly tried to touch his companion) at which point the guy attempted to brush his hand away, with the force an 8-year-old might use on his annoying little brother who won't stop pestering him.

While I think on paper it’s commendable that Neko stood behind Wasif -- and her being big-sister protective and empathetic (even to a fault) struck me as on brand from what little I know about her -- it seemed cruelly myopic to punish all of her fans present for the behavior of one person. What’s more, she chose to fully accept just one side of the story. (Clearly Wasif sold her a bill of victimhood goods because, frankly, I don't think the guy did anything worthy of ejection.)
Someone close to the situation told me the band came very near not performing at all, which might have been for the better. I considered following others out but opted to stay -- it was a birthday celebration, after all -- and it ended up feeling like a rushed and joyless affair that only went on because she couldn't afford (monetarily) not to go through with it -- for reasons that still are not clear. (The guy had been evicted!)
I was also told that it's "worth knowing" that "you don't always know what someone's going through and what it takes to go on. One thing can trigger another thing can trigger another thing."
I couldn't agree more, which is why I don’t fault the crowd -- not there to see Wasif -- that sat politely during his performance and clapped after each song. We lived up to our end of the bargain. (No one jumped on the stage and got in his face.) Plus it cuts both ways. Wasif had no idea what the audience members were going through or what it took for him and his companion to travel to the show, so trying to touch him (or them) without consent hardly seemed well-advised. One would think someone as seemingly sensitive as Neko Case would be appreciative of that fact -- surely she understands the importance of respecting people’s boundaries and the meaning of consent -- rather than taking it out on a crowd of people who adore her.

The onus isn’t on the audience to be an interactive part of a show. But if a performer chooses to go down that road, it's very easy to tell who is game. If someone isn’t -- even if they’re not “nice” about it -- a professional simply moves on. What a professional doesn't do is throw a tantrum on stage and poison the entire event for the person kind enough to ask them to provide support.
Worth noting that we heard that the police were called but Wasif declined to speak with them. Make of that what you will.
In happier times ...