Tuesday, July 18, 2023

Remains of the Day (07/18)











HBO: I have mixed feelings about "The Stroll," a new documentary on Max that "tells the history of New York's Meatpacking District from the perspective of transgender sex workers who lived and worked there." The footage and interviews are riveting  -- I moved to NYC during this era's heyday and used to frequent bars in the area, including Hell and the Lure, so ate up all the old clips -- yet for a film that won a special jury prize for clarity of vision at Sundance, its point is deeply muddled. Given the lack of employment opportunities for trans people, it's a fact that many turn to sex work to survive. But the film seems to spend an inordinate amount of time harping on the notion that T people haven't been given their due from the LGB community -- specifically white lesbian, gay and bisexual people -- while largely ignoring who the real villains are here. 

Lesbian, gay and bisexual people (white or otherwise) aren't the ones who criminalized prostitution. Lesbian, gay and bisexual people aren't the ones who passed so-called "walking while trans" laws, making trans people's lives miserable. Lesbian, gay and bisexual people aren't the ones murdering trans women of color. And above all else, it isn't lesbian, gay and bisexual people who are throwing their trans children of color out on the street just for being who they are. Many of the gals interviewed were very endearing, making the film highly watchable. But it was equally frustrating feeling like no one in the room ever seemed to recognize what the real problems are. (Where was the PFLAG outreach to communities of color? Where was the focus on legalizing sex work the way others pushed to decriminalize marijuana? Muscular white guys on a Pride float aren't what's making trans people's lives more difficult than they need to be.) 

Instead, the residents of the West Village who objected to people having sex outside their apartments are almost made out to be as problematic as the cops raping sex workers in exchange for not arresting them. (I'm sorry, but there's nothing wrong with not wanting to see someone getting sucked off in a car when you're just trying to go to the corner to buy a quart of milk.) While well-meaning, the film's message is all over the map and confusing. Seeing some of the women watch and then try to judge RuPaul's lightweight visit to the hooking area back in the day on a campy cable access TV show through a 2023 lens only reiterated my ambivalence.





Hot Cat of the Day: Reach out and touch somebody's paw ...

3 comments:

Jaradon said...

Ben Cohen is a beautiful man I'm sure the show will find a way of getting him naked ( well at least shirtless) And what is the big deal with Tom Holland playing gay- he is an actor

GL said...

Thanks for the commentary. I find all documentaries lately very one sided and pushing a singular narrative. In many cases, it’s hard to find anyone with some self reflection. It seems they would rather be portrayed as a victim. Maybe I’m off topic here and missing the point, but thanks for letting me get that off my chest.

Jaradon said...

I'm not surprise the documentary like tries to rewrite gay history to fit the current cultural narrative but most films now do that