In a compelling piece in the Guardian, the Blondie singer outlines why she’s joining the crusade to demand better payments for musicians from the video streaming service:
Music fuels YouTube’s success. Music has helped the video site become the No 1 destination for music online. Music has also helped make YouTube’s parent company, Google, which bought it in 2006, become the world’s second largest corporation. Music matters. Artists matter. Our large community of hardworking artists is being exploited to make a very small percentage of people extremely rich.
I say this because recently Ben Watt -- whose complete catalogue I own dating back to his 1982 solo album and his first work with Everything But the Girl -- put out a new LP called "Fever Dream." In the past, I would have immediately bought the CD.. But in recent years, I have been buying the download from Amazon or iTunes. But late last month I was at work and noticed the entire album was streaming on Pitchfork, so I put on my schmancy headphones and listened to the whole thing at my desk, not wanting to wait till I got home to buy it. It sounded great. But it was at that moment that I first realized if I wanted to listen to it again, I could just pull up the site and have at it. Although I've always loved collecting music, now that there's no physical product involved, it suddenly dawned on me -- as I'm sure it has every Spotify/Apple Music/Etc. user in the world ages ago -- that there really wasn't a huge difference between listening to it via purchase on iTunes and (in this case) Pitchfork -- an album I would probably listen to very sporadically anyway, so why spend the money?
I'm now part of the problem. (Are you happy now, techies?) But now that this genie is out of the bottle, the only logical way to fix the situation is to increase the royalties paid to artists whose music is being used. It will still be a fraction of what they used to be paid, but at least it's something. (Before you hate me, remember this: I still buy Ben Watt concert tickets!)
How ironic that Blondie's "Dreaming" makes for the perfect parody of everything that's wrong with the music industry today!
Apparently the war for music streaming marketshare has become more important than actually SELLING music, because twice I've tried to buy albums recently and Amazon did everything in its power to refuse to SELL it to me, offering to let me stream it for FREE. (Huh?) My brother also notes the other bizarre thing -- that they charge less for CD plus MP3s than they do for MP3s alone. I think I"m starting to see why artists can't make any money off recorded music anymore -- it all goes to Apple, Spotify and the like.
I'll admit that I often don't even watch the viral videos I post. I don't have ADHT, but I find most of them tedious, no matter how concise. But this one about music streaming is completely sublime. Although I disagree with everything the creator believes, it's such a brilliant parody of a brilliant Blondie song that I could not resist its charms!
I’ve been a professional musician and songwriter for over 40 years. I live and breathe music. I also own thousands of albums and CD’s … but they sit in my closet because…
I prefer to STREAM MUSIC!!!!
I know that the drop in physical record sales has financially hurt many of my fellow musicians. I feel for them but as the music business evolves there will be winner and losers. I believe streaming services such as Spotify, Apple Music and YouTube Red will eventually have a hundred million subscribers worldwide … then more money will flow.
I also understand that fidelity is an issue. Every musician I know works hard to make the best sounding music possible but I also know that most people listen to mp3’s on cheap ear buds negating a good portion of their efforts.
The point is convenience trumps everything and we are never going back to what once was …
I don’t own a typewriter, I don’t have a landline phone, I don’t have cable TV, and I don’t mail letters.
I shop online, I pay my bills online, I read the newspaper online, I communicate with my friends and family online…. and every song that I ever want to hear is available online … instantly.
I love my vinyl but when I want to listen to music…. I stream.
Andy Shernoff
- Thanks to Chris Stein, who may not share my feelings about streaming but allowed me to have fun with his song,
- Tricia Scotti for the wonderful vocal
- Carla Rhodes for the concept and Chris Manley for the video.
Regular readers know that I'm the unofficial president of the Rosanne Cash Fan Club, as well as being her (semi)official biographer. But this isn't really about that. As a result of a recent social-media post she made in which she called music streaming "just dressed-up piracy," the singer/songwriter has come under attack from various people, including Bruce Houghton of Hyperbot, which describes itself as the leading music industry and technology news blog..
I'm old, so have never understood the allure of streaming music. (I still buy multiple copies of the same CD from different outlets to ensure I get every bonus track!) But reading what Ms. Cash has to say about it should be a real eyeopener to everybody, not just creative types. Ironically, many of the people going after her are her own fans, and I think I know why. I believe some felt attacked -- I can't find it, but I remember her saying streaming and stealing off the Internet were the "same" thing, which obviously they are not -- and because they're probably paying for Spotify or Pandora some felt she was acting like they were just as bad as people who are illegally downloading music off the Internet. (I was even a little taken aback and I don't even stream music.) I think she was being deliberately hyperbolic because it REALLY is criminal what's going on -- it's just not the fans' fault.
Read what Mr. Houghton had to say HERE and then check out Rosanne's response below and you'll see what I mean. (BTW: I stole this from her Facebook page, which you can "like" for yourself HERE!)
I will refrain from addressing you as a ‘little boy’ even though you referred to me as a ‘little girl’ in your recent column (http://www.hypebot.com/hypebot/2014/10/streaming-is-just-dressed-up-piracy-says-rosanne-cash.html). I understood that we disagreed on issues concerning streaming and fair compensation for musicians and songwriters, but I must say you lost all credibility with me when you stooped to that breathtakingly sexist insult. (You also misspelled my name in the subtitle of your article, which doesn’t inspire confidence in your research skills.)
Setting your lapses of courtesy and spelling aside, I welcome the opportunity to respond and to state my position on artists’ rights for your readers. I first want to clarify that I am not unhappy with my audience, nor do I criticize them in any way. I treasure them. I criticize the corporations that profit from the music without paying for it properly—and improper payment runs the gamut from ridiculous underpayment to downright theft.
I have no problem with technology. My issues are with businesses that use my work—and the work of all musicians and songwriters—and don’t pay for it. The CEO of Pandora took home more in stock options in 2013—$29,167,388—than it paid in that year to all American songwriters combined (http://insiders.morningstar.com/trading/executive-compensation.action?t=P).
Total revenues from the US record industry have fallen from $14.6 to 7 billion in the last fifteen years, which is a decline of 52 per cent (http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/music/posts/la-et-ms-music-industry-revenue-riaa-report-streaming-digital-20140318-story.html). Amidst this economic Depression for an industry that provides the primary investment and promotion for new talent, music is being treated as a ‘loss leader’ to attract advertising, venture capital funding, and speculative stock sales for the likes of Pandora, Spotify and Google/ YouTube (and even terrestrial radio—in no other profession or industry in America can you make free use of a person’s copyright as bait for your own financial gain.)
Of course, I do receive compensation for sales of my albums on iTunes and from brick-and-mortar stores, as one reader commented, but artists are entitled to be paid fairly on all platforms, not just iTunes and record stores. This isn’t about artists deserving huge riches, but the principle of getting a fair cut when our work is being used for obviously commercial purposes. Many musicians are struggling desperately to stay afloat. This is particularly true for non-performing songwriters, who cannot compensate for the loss of income in royalties by touring.
The fact that the major labels are complicit in profiting from streaming outlets, as also mentioned in the comments section, is indeed true. Perhaps the $104 I received for 600,000 streams in an 18-month period might have been more if I were on an indie label instead of a major—perhaps even ten times more. But you must see that even the higher (in theory) indie rate is still unsustainable, and the major/indie discussion is a red herring—it does not address the most basic problem, which is that the tech companies are making billions by using our music and musicians are being forced out of the business.
I ask the fans directly to think about this: the next time you download music, ask yourself who is getting paid: the tech corporation, or the artist? Who is liable for infringement: the corporation, or you, the consumer? How is it that multi-billion dollar corporations have managed to pull off this sleight of hand for so long, to indemnify themselves against the artist and the consumer by creating a system that rakes in billions for themselves and mocks and manipulates both artist and user?
I’m not worried about me. I’m worried about the entire next generation of songwriters and musicians who are dispirited and feel completely devalued and who give up their dreams in order to earn a decent paycheck. For every Mick Jagger, there are 10,000 in the trenches who feel they are no longer valued members of society because people who will pay ten bucks for a cappuccino and a muffin will not pay the same amount to buy an album of original music that an artist may have put years of heart and sweat into making.
Many members of Congress are aware of the potentially catastrophic situation for creators and are studying the landscape to better understand the situation and make it work for artists. Bills have already been introduced to remedy some of the most egregious injustices (https://www.congress.gov/bill/113th-congress/house-bill/4772).
The music business, that not-so-long ago sustained the careers of artists at all levels, is in danger of collapse. I have faith that at some point, the current models will be revised so that the streaming and tech companies which profit from our work realize that they will put themselves out of business if they don’t fairly compensate the creators they use for their gain. Then again, I may be giving them too much credit. As in the case of the CEO of Pandora, an unprofitable company, they might be more interested in cashing out millions in future stock options than in building sustainable businesses that benefit artists on the ground.
In the meantime, legions of songwriters and musicians will divert or abandon their creative work in order to find better ways to feed their families, and that is a ‘loss leader’ that history will never replace.
We're down to the final eight men and eight women in New York -- predictions welcome in the comments. Full report from around the ground...
Fake Jan Alert
My blog is featured in Susan Olsen's tell-all about the ill-fated "Brady Bunch Variety Hour"!
Little Kenny
Growing up in Madison Heights, Mich.
Back to the Old House
The Web leads to an unexpected return to a house I grew up in.
Oceans 11
Carlsbad, Calif. (2008)
1983
Go Behind the Music of my high-school band, A La Plage
A Death in the Family
Little Larry left us too soon.
Once I Had a Love
With Debbie Harry
'Jungle' Fever
With Robert Buckley
Roger & Me
With Roger Federer
Step Brother McMullen
With Ed Burns
Headline News
With Thomas Roberts
Disclaimer
The views expressed on this blog belong to me -- and me alone -- and are not a reflection of my employers past, present or future.
All photos are shared under the fair use doctrine (17 U.S.C. § 107). If you would like any image removed, please contact me and I will promptly comply.
Click to revisit the heyday of Chelsea's 8th Avenue
My blog is featured in Susan Olsen's tell-all about the ill-fated "Brady Bunch Variety Hour"!
Growing up in Madison Heights, Mich.
The Web leads to an unexpected return to a house I grew up in.
Carlsbad, Calif. (2008)
Go Behind the Music of my high-school band, A La Plage
Little Larry left us too soon.
With Debbie Harry
With Robert Buckley
With Roger Federer
With Ed Burns
With Thomas Roberts
You've read the blog -- now read the book!
My memoir is available at Three Lives & Co. in the West Village
Like my book on Facebook here.
