Taylor Hicks: America's Next Top Widdler

"American Idol" voters decided it's not quite time for Taylor Hicks to return to shuffleboard city, instead choosing to send Elliott Yamin home. Now it's Old Man Hicks vs. Katharine McPhee for the top prize ...

Read: Another 'Idol' Gets the Boot, Leaving Two

Simon Says: Cowell Picks Hicks to Be Next 'Idol'